Skip to content

Using the Likelihood Ratio in Bloodstain Pattern Analysis

Journal: Journal of Forensic Sciences
Published: 2021
Primary Author: Daniel Attinger
Secondary Authors: Kris De Brabanter, Christophe Champod

There is an apparent paradox that the likelihood ratio (LR) approach is an appropriate measure of the weight of evidence when forensic findings have to be evaluated in court, while it is typically not used by bloodstain pattern analysis (BPA) experts. This commentary evaluates how the scope and methods of BPA relate to several types of evaluative propositions and methods to which LRs are applicable. As a result of this evaluation, we show how specificities in scope (BPA being about activities rather than source identification), gaps in the underlying science base, and the reliance on a wide range of methods render the use of LRs in BPA more complex than in some other forensic disciplines. Three directions are identified for BPA research and training, which would facilitate and widen the use of LRs: research in the underlying physics; the development of a culture of data sharing; and the development of training material on the required statistical background. An example of how recent fluid dynamics research in BPA can lead to the use of LR is provided. We conclude that an LR framework is fully applicable to BPA, provided methodic efforts and significant developments occur along the three outlined directions.

Related Resources

Significance of image brightness levels for PRNU camera identification

Significance of image brightness levels for PRNU camera identification

A forensic investigator performing source identification on a questioned image from a crime aims to identify the unknown camera that acquired the image. On the camera sensor, minute spatial variations…
Methodological problems in every black-box study of forensic firearm comparisons

Methodological problems in every black-box study of forensic firearm comparisons

Reviews conducted by the National Academy of Sciences (2009) and the President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (2016) concluded that the field of forensic firearm comparisons has not…
First impressions matter: Mundane obstacles to a forensic device for probabilistic reporting in fingerprint analysis

First impressions matter: Mundane obstacles to a forensic device for probabilistic reporting in fingerprint analysis

This article investigates why statistical reasoning has had little impact on the practice of friction ridge (or ‘fingerprint’) examination, despite both interest and some modest scientific progress toward this goal.…
A Dirichlet process model for directional-linear data with application to bloodstain pattern analysis

A Dirichlet process model for directional-linear data with application to bloodstain pattern analysis

Directional data require specialized models because of the non-Euclidean nature of their domain. When a directional variable is observed jointly with linear variables, modeling their dependence adds an additional layer…