Skip to content

Subjective Bayesian testing using calibrated prior probabilities

Journal: Brazilian Journal of Probability of Statistics
Published: 2018
Primary Author: Dan J. Spitzner
Research Area: Forensic Statistics

This article proposes a calibration scheme for Bayesian testing that coordinates analytically-derived statistical performance considerations with expert opinion. In other words, the scheme is effective and meaningful for incorporating objective elements into subjective Bayesian inference. It explores a novel role for default priors as anchors for calibration rather than substitutes for prior knowledge. Ideas are developed for use with multiplicity adjustments in multiple-model contexts, and to address the issue of prior sensitivity of Bayes factors. Along the way, the performance properties of an existing multiplicity adjustment related to the Poisson distribution are clarified theoretically. Connections of the overall calibration scheme to the Schwarz criterion are also explored. The proposed framework is examined and illustrated on a number of existing data sets related to problems in clinical trials, forensic pattern matching, and log-linear models methodology.

Related Resources

Significance of image brightness levels for PRNU camera identification

Significance of image brightness levels for PRNU camera identification

A forensic investigator performing source identification on a questioned image from a crime aims to identify the unknown camera that acquired the image. On the camera sensor, minute spatial variations…
Methodological problems in every black-box study of forensic firearm comparisons

Methodological problems in every black-box study of forensic firearm comparisons

Reviews conducted by the National Academy of Sciences (2009) and the President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (2016) concluded that the field of forensic firearm comparisons has not…
First impressions matter: Mundane obstacles to a forensic device for probabilistic reporting in fingerprint analysis

First impressions matter: Mundane obstacles to a forensic device for probabilistic reporting in fingerprint analysis

This article investigates why statistical reasoning has had little impact on the practice of friction ridge (or ‘fingerprint’) examination, despite both interest and some modest scientific progress toward this goal.…
A Dirichlet process model for directional-linear data with application to bloodstain pattern analysis

A Dirichlet process model for directional-linear data with application to bloodstain pattern analysis

Directional data require specialized models because of the non-Euclidean nature of their domain. When a directional variable is observed jointly with linear variables, modeling their dependence adds an additional layer…