Skip to content

Science Bench Book for Judges

Journal: National Judicial College
Published: 2019
Primary Author: Alicia Carriquiry (16 contributing authors)
Secondary Authors: Eryn Blagg
Research Area: Forensic Statistics

The National Judicial College and the Justice Speakers Institute, LLC developed this bench book with support from the State Justice Institute to help judges determine the admissibility of evidence based on sound forensic science. The fact is, few judges were scientists in a previous career. The scientific method is not second nature to most, and few subscribe to scientific journals. In a worst-case scenario, a judge could admit so-called “scientific testimony” even after the scientific community had discredited it. This first-of-its kind book for state court judges is a practical guide to the key types of scientific evidence judges are likely to encounter on the bench. It is the work of expert judges and practitioners. All judges, new or experienced, will find it helpful when considering complex scientific evidence.

Related Resources

Score-based Likelihood Ratios Using Stylometric Text Embeddings

Score-based Likelihood Ratios Using Stylometric Text Embeddings

We consider the problem setting in which we have two sets of texts in digital form and would like to quantify our beliefs that the two sets of texts were…
Statistics and its Applications in Forensic Science and the Criminal Justice System

Statistics and its Applications in Forensic Science and the Criminal Justice System

This presentation is from the 2024 Joint Statistical Meetings (JSM), Portland, Oregon, August 3-8, 2024.
Algorithmic matching of striated tool marks

Algorithmic matching of striated tool marks

Automatic matching algorithms for assessing the similarity between striation marks have been investigated for bullet lands and some tool marks, such as screwdrivers. We are interested in the investigation of…
Silencing the Defense Expert

Silencing the Defense Expert

In the wake of the 2009 NRC and 2016 PCAST Reports, the Firearms and Toolmark (FATM) discipline has come under increasing scrutiny. Validation studies like AMES I, Keisler, AMES II,…