Forensic science often involves the comparison of crime-scene evidence to a known-source sample to determine if the evidence and the reference sample came from the same source. Even as forensic analysis tools become increasingly objective and automated, final source identifications are often left to individual examiners’ interpretation of the evidence. Each source identification relies on judgements about the features and quality of the crime-scene evidence that may vary from one examiner to the next. The current approach to characterizing uncertainty in examiners’ decision-making has largely centered around the calculation of error rates aggregated across examiners and identification tasks, without taking into account these variations in behavior. We propose a new approach using IRT and IRT-like models to account for differences among examiners and additionally account for the varying difficulty among source identification tasks. In particular, we survey some recent advances (Luby 2019a) in the application of Bayesian psychometric models, including simple Rasch models as well as more elaborate decision tree models, to fingerprint examiner behavior.
Psychometric analysis of forensic examiner behavior

Journal: Behaviormetrika
Published: 2020
Primary Author: Amanda Luby
Secondary Authors: Anjali Mazumber, Brian Junker
Type: Publication
Research Area: Latent Print
Related Resources
Latent Print Quality in Blind Proficiency Testing: Using Quality Metrics to Examine Laboratory Performance
Presented at American Association of Forensic Sciences (AAFS) 2021
The Implementation of a Blind Quality Control Program in a Forensic Laboratory
Presented at American Association of Forensic Sciences (AAFS) 2021
A Field Analysis of Laboratory Case Processing: Latent Print Comparison and Examiner Conclusions
Presented at American Association of Forensic Sciences (AAFS)
Psychometrics for Forensic Fingerprint Comparisons
Forensic science often involves the evaluation of crime-scene evidence to determine whether it matches a known-source sample, such as whether a fingerprint or DNA was left by a suspect or…