Person sitting on a bench, reading a newspaper, face hidden behind the paper.

Posted March 26, 2018


CSAFE Director Alicia Carriquiry was recently interviewed by news organization Gizmodo about the new Department of Justice (DOJ) policies to improve standards around forensic science in federal laboratories. In an effort to standardize the way forensic scientists communicate about forensic evidence, the DOJ has issued uniform language requirements for forensic scientists to use during testimony and reporting.  For example, when examiners report about the results of fingerprint analysis, the new guidelines prohibit the use of the term “individualize” because it implies that results are the based on comparison with every known fingerprint. As a result,  federal forensic scientists cannot say that they are 100 percent certain about their conclusion.

While these new standards add much-need consistency, the article “Most Forensic Science is Bogus. Will New Federal Rules Help” points out that they do not address the foundational problem facing forensic science, which is that some of the tools used in criminal invesitgations aren’t rooted in scientifically sound principles. Carriquiry emphasizes the need for scientists and organizations such as CSAFE to continue investigating ways to improve the methods forensic pracitioners use.

From the article:

Language standards should only be an intermediary step on the way to that better science, said Alicia Carriquiry, director of the Center for Statistics and Applications in Forensic Evidence.

“I hope the DOJ’s message on this is that this is acceptable language for the state of the science today, but we need to continue to push the science forward,” she said.

Carriquiry would also like to see independent scientists contributing to the work being done on forensic science standards at the DOJ. “You learn more when you have a larger group of scientists involved,” she said.

Read the full article on the Gizmodo website.

 

From the Blog

Journal article titled "Challenges in Modeling...Images as Forensic Evidence" by Kafadar and Carriquiry.

Two Journals for Sharing Your Forensic Science and Statistics Research

If you’re looking for a journal to showcase your latest research findings, consider exploring these …

NIST sign outside, surrounded by flowers and trees, on a sunny day.

NIST Report Highlights Key Challenges in Forensic Science and Provides Strategies for Addressing Them

In September, the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) released a new report titled …

Recent Posts

ICFIS 2026 logo features a clock tower and the Forensic Inference and Statistics name.

Keynote Speakers Announced for ICFIS 2026

August 10, 2026

The Scientific Committee for the 12th International Conference on Forensic Inference and Statistics is pleased to announce the keynote speakers …

2026 Wisconsin NAFSB Conference logo on a dark blue background.

CSAFE Researchers will be Panel Speakers at NAFSB 2026 Conference

August 7, 2026

The annual National Association of Forensic Science Boards (NAFSB) Conference will be Oct. 13-16 at the Milwaukee Crime Lab Bureau …

ICFIS 2026 logo features a clock tower and the Forensic Inference and Statistics name.

ICFIS 2026 Moves Online, Abstract Deadline Extended to Aug. 17

July 27, 2026

The 12th International Conference on Forensic Inference and Statistics (ICFIS) will now be an online-only event, allowing participants from around the world …

Top