In recent years, the forensic community has pushed to increase the scientific basis of forensic evidence, which has included proficiency testing for fingerprint analysts. We used proficiency testing data collected by Collaborative Testing Services in which 431 fingerprint analysts were asked to identify the source of latent prints. The data were analysed using a Rasch model with a Bayesian estimation approach. Although these data provide valuable information about the relative proficiency of the examiners and the relative difficulty of the questions, it does not necessarily extrapolate onto general performance of examiners or difficulty in casework, which we show through sensitivity analysis and simulation. We show that a Bayesian Item Response Theory (IRT) analysis provides a deeper understanding of analysts’ proficiency and question difficulty than other forms of analysis. A large-scale adoption of IRT in this area would provide both more precise estimates of proficiency and quantitative evidence for the relative difficulty of different questions.
Proficiency Testing of Forensic Fingerprint Examiners with Bayesian Item Response Theory

Journal: Law, Probability and Risk
Published: 2018
Primary Author: Amanda S. Luby
Secondary Authors: Joseph B. Kadane
Type: Publication
Research Area: Latent Print
Related Resources
Does image editing improve the quality of latent prints? An analysis of image-editing techniques in one crime laboratory
Field research within latent print comparison has remained sparse in the context of an otherwise growing body of literature examining the discipline. Studies examining how ACE-V procedures are implemented within…
Modeling Covarying Responses in Complex Tasks
In testing situations, participants are often asked for supplementary re- sponses in addition to the primary response of interest, which may in- clude quantities like confidence or reported difficulty. These…
Analyzing spatial responses: A comparison of IRT- based approaches, Conference Presentation
We investigate two approaches for analyzing spatial coordinate responses using models inspired by Item Response Theory (IRT). In the first, we use a two-stage approach to first construct a pseudoresponse…
Characterizing Variability in Forensic Decision-Making with Item Response Theory
This presentation is from the 2022 Joint Statistical Meetings