Over the past year, we have had the opportunity to scan several Hamby Sets from different Forensic Labs. Scans from another two Hamby sets are available from the National Ballistics and Toolmarks Research Database. We were also given two clone sets by Prof Hamby.
This gave us at least twelve bullets from each of the barrels and allowed us to turn the tables: Instead of matching bullets to bullets, we can now take a look at how well each of the ten barrels marks and how much variability we see in the scores for each of the barrels.
Using the automatic matching algorithm, we were also able to evaluate the clone bullets in more detail and compare scores from clone to clone and clone to bullet. Results show that clones generally result in lower scores, but are still identified as matches to bullets from the same barrel.
Automatic Matching of Scans from Hamby Sets: Friends, False Friends, and Clones

Conference/Workshop:
AFTE Annual Training Seminar
AFTE Annual Training Seminar
Published: 2019
Primary Author: Heike Hofmann
Secondary Authors: Susan VanderPlas, Alicia Carriquiry
Type: Presentation Slides
Research Area: Firearms and Toolmarks
Related Resources
An Open-Source Implementation of the CMPS Algorithm for Assessing Similarity of Bullets
In this paper, we introduce the R package cmpsR, an open-source implementation of the Congruent Matching Profile Segments (CMPS) method developed at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)…
A Pipeline for Cartridge Case Comparisons
We introduce novel sub-procedures in the pre-processing, comparison and similarity feature steps. The sub-procedures result in an improved error rate compared to our implementation of the CMC method while also…
Affect of Manufacturer Finishing Methods on Subclass Characteristics Production on Breech Faces
The following is a presentation given at Association for Firearms and Toolmarks (AFTE) (2022).
An Algorithm for Forensic Toolmark Comparisons
Forensic handheld toolmark examiners currently compare toolmarks (e.g. scratch marks on wire found as part of an explosive device, or on a door frame after someone broke into a house)…