When a gun is fired, it leaves marks on cartridge cases that are thought to be unique to the gun. In current practice, firearms examiners inspect cartridge cases for “sufficient agreement,” in which case they conclude that they come from the same gun, testifying in courts as such. A 2016 President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology report questioned the scientific validity of such analysis (President’s Committee of Advisors on Science and Technology, Washington, DC, Executive Office of the President). One recommendation was to convert firearms analysis to an objective method. We propose a fully automated, open‐source method for comparing breechface marks on cartridge cases using 2D optical images. We improve on existing methodology by automating the selection of marks, and removing the effects of circular symmetry. We propose an empirical computation of a “random match probability” given a known database, which can be used to quantify the weight of evidence. We demonstrate an improvement in accuracy on images from controlled test fires.
A Fully Automatic Method for Comparing Cartridge Case Images

Journal: Journal of Forensic Sciences
Published: 2017
Primary Author: Xiao Hui Tai
Secondary Authors: William F. Eddy, M. Stats
Type: Publication
Research Area: Firearms and Toolmarks
Related Resources
An Open-Source Implementation of the CMPS Algorithm for Assessing Similarity of Bullets
In this paper, we introduce the R package cmpsR, an open-source implementation of the Congruent Matching Profile Segments (CMPS) method developed at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)…
A Pipeline for Cartridge Case Comparisons
We introduce novel sub-procedures in the pre-processing, comparison and similarity feature steps. The sub-procedures result in an improved error rate compared to our implementation of the CMC method while also…
Affect of Manufacturer Finishing Methods on Subclass Characteristics Production on Breech Faces
The following is a presentation given at Association for Firearms and Toolmarks (AFTE) (2022).
An Algorithm for Forensic Toolmark Comparisons
Forensic handheld toolmark examiners currently compare toolmarks (e.g. scratch marks on wire found as part of an explosive device, or on a door frame after someone broke into a house)…